Apple sues OpenAI in Northern California, naming Chief Hardware Officer Tang Tan and engineer Chang Liu over trade-secret theft it says ran "at every level"
Apple's complaint accuses OpenAI's hardware chief Tang Tan, a former Apple vice president, of directing Apple candidates to bring "actual parts" to OpenAI interviews for show-and-tell, and accuses former Apple senior electrical engineer Chang Liu of skipping his exit interview, keeping his laptop, and exploiting a post-departure Apple cloud bug to download more than a thousand pages of confidential technical documents. The suit arrives four months after Apple confirmed the revamped Siri will run on Google Gemini instead of OpenAI's models, and Apple frames the two decisions as connected.
Business Today · 2026-07-11 · Source ↗ ·
Apple sues OpenAI in Northern California, naming Chief Hardware Officer Tang Tan and engineer Chang Liu over trade-secret theft it says ran "at every level"
Apple's complaint accuses OpenAI's hardware chief Tang Tan, a former Apple vice president, of directing Apple candidates to bring "actual parts" to OpenAI interviews for show-and-tell, and accuses former Apple senior electrical engineer Chang Liu of skipping his exit interview, keeping his laptop, and exploiting a post-departure Apple cloud bug to download more than a thousand pages of confidential technical documents. The suit arrives four months after Apple confirmed the revamped Siri will run on Google Gemini instead of OpenAI's models, and Apple frames the two decisions as connected.
Business Today · 2026-07-11 · Source ↗ ·
Apple filed suit against OpenAI, its hardware subsidiary IO Products, and two named former Apple employees in the US District Court for the Northern District of California late Friday, and the complaint circulated through wire coverage into Saturday morning. Business Today's July 11 story is the most complete public account of what the filing actually says. The named individual defendants are Tang Tan, now Chief Hardware Officer at OpenAI and previously a vice president at Apple, and Chang Liu, a former senior electrical engineer at Apple. The complaint is the first time Apple has taken a US frontier-AI lab to court, and it lands four months after Apple confirmed the autumn 2026 revamp of Siri will run on Google's Gemini rather than OpenAI's models.
The two allegations doing the work in the filing are specific. Apple claims Tan directed Apple engineers interviewing at OpenAI to bring "actual parts" from Apple products to their interviews so he and his team could run "show and tell" sessions and elicit confidential Apple information from candidates during the interview loop. Apple frames those sessions as a targeted intelligence-gathering process rather than a normal hiring practice. The second allegation concerns Liu. Apple says Liu never returned his company laptop, skipped his exit interview, and then exploited a bug in Apple's internal cloud storage that allowed a departed employee to reach files he no longer had entitlement to. Apple says Liu used that opening to download dozens of confidential files including over a thousand pages of technical documents on his way out the door.
"OpenAI, through its hardware subsidiary IO Products, engaged in a scheme to acquire Apple's trade secrets at every level of its organization."— Apple complaint, N.D. Cal., filed July 10 2026
The IO Products backdrop
Apple's suit lands on top of OpenAI's $6.4 billion acquisition of IO Products, the Jony Ive-founded hardware venture OpenAI closed earlier this year to build a family of AI-native consumer devices. IO Products staffed heavily out of Apple's Cupertino design and hardware ranks. Apple's complaint reads the hiring pattern as more than incidental. It ties the show-and-tell allegation directly to IO Products' recruiting pipeline and argues that OpenAI's device roadmap depends on know-how developed on Apple's dime. The two named defendants sit at nodes Apple chose deliberately: Tan is the most senior former Apple executive at OpenAI, and Liu allegedly walked out with the paperwork.
OpenAI's response was brief. A spokesperson told the BBC the company is reviewing Apple's complaint and denied any interest in another company's trade secrets. Neither Tan nor Liu commented publicly on Saturday. Apple did not put a dollar figure on damages in the initial filing, but the complaint asks for injunctive relief on IO Products' hardware program and a full accounting of any documents Liu allegedly retained. Trade-secret cases of this shape are slow, expensive, and rarely produce the injunctions plaintiffs open with, but they generate discovery that runs through years of internal email at both companies.
The Siri-Gemini link
Business Today reports the case comes "just months after Apple confirmed it would build its revamped Siri assistant on Google's Gemini AI models instead of OpenAI's ChatGPT technology, ending speculation that ChatGPT would remain central to Apple Intelligence." That timeline stitches together. Apple picked Gemini in March. Apple filed against OpenAI in July. The Siri-Gemini switch is now the operational fact underneath the litigation, and it means Apple no longer has a direct commercial reason to keep the relationship civil. Whatever residual leverage OpenAI had via Siri distribution is gone; the litigation reads as Apple burning that bridge intentionally.
"We have no interest in other companies' trade secrets. We are reviewing Apple's complaint."— OpenAI spokesperson, statement to BBC, July 10 2026
What breaks next
Three immediate consequences. First, OpenAI's confidential S-1, filed June 8 for a targeted 2027 IPO, now carries a material disclosure item that has to appear in the amended registration. Trade-secret litigation with a Big Tech plaintiff and specific named executives is exactly the class of risk item underwriters push into the risk factors section. Second, IO Products' device roadmap is now on a clock. Discovery will surface which parts of the OpenAI hardware program relied on the allegedly appropriated material, and any injunctive risk on that program is what OpenAI actually cares about protecting. Third, this closes the era in which Big Tech and the frontier labs cooperated through commercial deals and cross-executive movement. The Apple–OpenAI partnership around ChatGPT-in-Siri was the standard bearer for that model. Apple's lawsuit against the same counterpart, over hires that supported the same product line, marks the point at which Apple stops treating OpenAI as a partner and starts treating it as a competitor to litigate against.