OpenAI's post appeared Tuesday afternoon in San Francisco and made the specific claim that Nearly 100 agents worked together for approximately 50 hours to produce our Euler regularity disproof and that 10,000 or so agents worked for 88 hours to produce the Navier-Stokes existence-and-smoothness proof, exchanging almost 5 million messages to each other. Sébastien Bubeck, the OpenAI researcher who led the effort, estimated the compute cost in the several-million-dollar range. The model that produced the proof is unreleased. OpenAI has not published the Lean file or the intermediate reasoning transcripts. Quanta Magazine's Erica Klarreich, who has been reporting on the effort, published the definitive Tuesday walk-through and framed the result as a claim rather than a settled proof: Lean-verified means the proof compiles, but a human still has to verify that what Lean is proving corresponds to the original Millennium Prize statement.
Twelve hours before the OpenAI post, Tristan Buckmaster of NYU Courant and Levent Alpöge of Anthropic released a Lean-verified proof of finite-time blowup for three fluid systems including 3D incompressible Euler, following a body of work by Diego Córdoba of ICMAT and Luis Martínez-Zoroa (currently at ETH Zürich) that has been building over the past three years. Buckmaster's public statement is that his private Codex sessions containing scratch-work and intermediate lemmas may have been accessible to OpenAI's research team, and that OpenAI began an intense push on the fluid-dynamics problems in the two weeks after his team's approach was shared with a Codex-adjacent collaborator. Buckmaster's exact framing on X read that the timing "is suspicious enough that I would want an audit." OpenAI's response was categorical: researchers and agents did not see any of their work through any means until they released it publicly, and no specific user data was accessed in order to solve this problem.
"The first LLM-generated proof Levent sent me was the most horrendous I have ever read. But there was a real result inside." — Tristan Buckmaster, NYU Courant, on the Buckmaster-Alpöge Euler blowup proof
What each team proved
Buckmaster and Alpöge's release covers Lean-verified proofs of finite-time singularity formation for three fluid PDE systems, most importantly the 3D incompressible Euler equations. Their work extends Córdoba and Martínez-Zoroa's earlier constructions with the addition of formal verification, and it is now sitting on Lean Zulip for line-by-line audit. OpenAI ceded 3D Euler priority to Buckmaster and Alpöge in its post. OpenAI's own claim is the harder one: existence-and-smoothness for the 3D incompressible Navier-Stokes equations, the exact statement the Clay Mathematics Institute posted a $1 million prize for in 2000. If the OpenAI proof holds under expert review, Bubeck and his team would have solved one of the seven Millennium Prize Problems using an autonomous agent swarm on a model OpenAI has not released, and the effort would be the first Millennium Prize claim made entirely by an AI system. Charles Fefferman, the Princeton mathematician who wrote the Clay Institute's official Navier-Stokes problem description, told Quanta he was thrilled the problem was solved and named Diego Córdoba and Luis Martínez-Zoroa as the underlying architects of the approach.
"Luis Martínez-Zoroa deserves a Fields Medal for this. He is the person who saw the way through." — Tristan Buckmaster, NYU, on the underlying construction
The Codex-access dispute
The Codex-access allegation is the piece of the story that will drive the next month of coverage. Buckmaster's account, given to Fortune's Sharon Goldman, is that he and Alpöge used private Codex sessions to draft, edit, and iterate on their proof between June and August. In late August he shared a summary of the approach with a Codex user who is also affiliated with OpenAI's research team. Two weeks later OpenAI's agent swarm produced its own proof on a closely related problem. OpenAI's response is that no specific user data was accessed, and that Codex-side telemetry can prove it. The company said it will publish an audit log demonstrating no researcher on the Navier-Stokes team had access to Buckmaster's Codex sessions. Simon Willison covered the dispute Tuesday evening on his blog and flagged the deeper structural question the incident raises: if a Codex-adjacent OpenAI researcher happened to be shown Buckmaster's approach through legitimate channels rather than a data-leak, would OpenAI still owe a citation and priority acknowledgment?
What Lean verification does and doesn't guarantee
Lean is a theorem prover developed at Microsoft Research whose type checker will only accept a proof term when every step type-checks against the axioms of dependent type theory. A Lean-verified proof is airtight in the sense that the derivation compiles. It does not guarantee that what the proof establishes is what a mathematician thought they were establishing. In the Navier-Stokes case the load-bearing translation step is the Lean formalization of the Millennium Prize statement itself. If OpenAI's Lean formalization diverges from Clay's precise statement of the smoothness condition, or if it introduces auxiliary axioms that mathematicians consider non-standard, the "proof" would need to be re-scrutinized. Buckmaster and Alpöge's Euler proof has already gone through a public Lean-file audit on the Lean Zulip and has held up. OpenAI has committed to publishing its Lean file within days, and the mathematical community's audit will begin as soon as the file is public.
Where this leaves the field
The result, if it holds, is the second Millennium Prize claim in a year (the Poincaré Conjecture was already solved by Grigori Perelman in 2003, and Fermat's Last Theorem was proved by Wiles in the 1990s outside the Millennium framework). It is the first Millennium claim generated by an AI system rather than a human. It is also the second machine-checkable AI-assisted proof of a major open problem this quarter, following Anthropic's Prove2Me-based Lean proof of Fermat's Last Theorem in July. What the Buckmaster dispute has already established, regardless of the audit outcome, is that the norms for authorship, data provenance, and credit-sharing in AI-assisted mathematics need to catch up with the technology by the end of 2026. Charles Fefferman closed the Quanta piece with a line worth quoting in full: "I don't yet know if these results will be verified. If they are, it will be a triumph. If they are not, it will be an important cautionary tale."