Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei published "We Must Pace the Frontier" on Saturday September 13, a 3,900-word essay proposing a three-step plan to slow the pace of AI capability improvement. Step one: embed third-party evaluators inside frontier labs at employee-level access. Anthropic named METR — the Model Evaluation and Threat Research organization founded by former OpenAI Preparedness team lead Beth Barnes — as its chosen partner and committed unilaterally to the arrangement. Step two: coordinate common safety benchmarks and capability limits across democratic AI companies, with the US government invoking antitrust safe harbor to mediate. Step three: pursue narrow guardrails with authoritarian governments on clearly dangerous applications, starting with biological weapons.
Sam Altman posted on X within hours agreeing with the plan and committing OpenAI to the same evaluator access. Elon Musk's response, quote-posted on the Amodei essay, was three words: "Dario is right." Satya Nadella pledged on X that Microsoft will open a MAI Code of Conduct for public consultation Monday morning and backed "deliberate pacing and independent evaluators," becoming the fourth frontier-lab CEO on record. That leaves Sundar Pichai's Google, Mark Zuckerberg's Meta and Alexandr Wang's Scale as the largest US-headquartered frontier holdouts.
"Committing to having independent evaluators with employee-like access is a great idea, and we will do the same."— Sam Altman, OpenAI CEO, on X, September 13
The three-step plan in specifics
Amodei's essay ties the evaluator step to a concrete access model: METR (or an equivalent auditor) receives internal accounts, sees training runs at the compute-cluster level, gets pre-release model access at every intermediate checkpoint, and can publish findings with a lab-review window bounded by a public disclosure calendar. The shared-benchmark step calls for a rotating chair among frontier labs to publish per-capability floors (biosecurity, cyber-offense, autonomous replication) with quarterly recalibration. The authoritarian-guardrails step names Chinese Foreign Ministry contacts and DeepSeek, Moonshot and Alibaba specifically as parties Anthropic has spoken with — a first for a US frontier lab in public print.
Two departures, five days, the same lab
Amodei's essay landed with two Anthropic safety departures fresh in the record. Jacob Coxon, a 27-year-old three-year pretraining researcher across OpenAI and Anthropic, published a resignation post on Monday September 8 that crossed 100 million views by Thursday, claiming leadership at both labs earnestly believes AI could kill everyone by decade's end and are racing anyway. The post was directly endorsed on X by Anthropic colleagues Evan Hubinger and Samuel Marks. On Saturday, Anthropic's Joe Benton — former manager of the Scalable Oversight team — announced his own resignation to join METR, telling NBC and Business Standard that colleagues still at Anthropic "experience genuine fear" about the pace of the work and naming Hubinger as one of the researchers publicly estimating greater than 10 percent probability of AI-caused human extinction.
"Dario is right."— Elon Musk, on X, quote-posting the essay
Political reception, two directions
Xi Jinping used the concluding session of the New Delhi BRICS summit to announce a five-point plan built around a Beijing-anchored BRICS AI open-source community and a call for a "consensus-based global AI governance framework." Donald Trump used a Doonbeg press gaggle to dismiss the pacing calls as "negative forces" and reaffirmed the "whoever wins AI wins" posture. House Speaker Mike Johnson framed any pacing legislation as "a gift to Beijing" in caucus communications, effectively killing the near-term legislative track for Rep. Sam Liccardo's letter urging the House to cancel October recess. Rishi Sunak, now an Anthropic senior adviser, wrote in a weekend newspaper column that "inaction is no longer an option. Leaders urgently need to show us that humans are setting the pace and are still in control." Former White House AI czar David Sacks used weekend media appearances to accuse Amodei, Altman and Musk of building "a cartel" and dressing "market consolidation as altruism."
Fortune published a parallel Altman interview on Friday confirming OpenAI will not IPO in 2026 ("I would say not 2026") because doing so would be an "ill-advised moment" given the safety work still ahead. The Amodei-Altman-Musk-Nadella lineup, the Coxon-Benton departures and Altman's IPO-delay comment all landed inside the same 96-hour window as Anthropic's Nasdaq IPO selection, which Business Insider reported Sunday targets an October roadshow at roughly $2 trillion valuation. The pacing conversation is now visibly entangled with the capital-markets narrative it hopes to constrain.